In John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men, George was justified to kill Lennie. One reason why George was justified to kill Lennie is because he was a threat to society. Lennie’s wrongdoings have only escalated over the years; George had no way of knowing what Lennie could do next.
Why is it good that George killed Lennie?
Since Lennie killed Curley’s wife he was a fugitive, and anyone who killed him is just. In the novel of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, the character George is justified in killing Lennie because of his actions caused by his disabilities allowing for a better life. George’s decision on killing Lennie was the right one.
Should George have killed Lennie debate?
George killing Lennie was justified because had to think about Lennie’s life ahead if he didn ‘t make this choice. George making this choice was right because Lennie had unknowingly brought a threat among people, Lennie had died much quicker and painless, and Lennie was basically George’s responsibility.
Should George have shot Lennie?
George definitely did the right thing. If he did not kill Lennie, Curly would definitely have had him tortured and painfully killed. Shooting him was painless.
Should George have killed Lennie quotes?
I ain’t mad, an’ I ain’t now. That’s a thing I want ya to know” (Steinbeck 106). This quote shows that George is killing Lennie for Lennie’s own good. George realizes that if the other men were to find Lennie alive they would have tortured him.
What happens after George kills Lennie?
After killing Lennie, George will never fulfill the dream of life on the farm. At the beginning of the novel, when George describes the dream to Lennie, he also describes other ranchers: “’They got no family. … They come to a ranch an’ work up a stake and then they go inta town and blow their stake…
What does George say before he kills Lennie?
What does George say to Lennie before shooting him? He tells Lennie that he is a bad man and that he deserves to die. He tells Lennie that he has no other choice but to shoot him since it’s the law.
Why was George justified in killing Lennie essay?
Since Lennie killed Curley’s wife he was a fugitive, and anyone who killed him is just. In the novel of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, the character George is justified in killing Lennie because of his actions caused by his disabilities allowing for a better life.
Did George make the right decision when he killed Lennie essay?
Argumentative Essay Of Mice And Men
In “Of Mice and Men” by John Steinbeck, George made the right decision in shooting Lennie because Lennie did not know his own strength. … However, the other side might argue that Lennie did not mean to kill Curley’s wife, thus he deserves to live.
Was the mercy killing of Lennie justified?
Therefore George’s decision to kill Lennie is justified because he was doing it to protect him from the other men that would want him to suffer, he needed to do it himself or he would feel guilty about not killing him, and that Lennie would mess up again and that because of Lennie’s actions, the dream would never come …
What were some of the reasons George should not have killed Lennie were there any better alternatives?
Lennie did not mean to kill them on purpose. One reason George should not have killed Lennie because everything that happened, was an accident. Lennie did not mean to kill Curley’s wife or the puppy. In the passage, Of mice and men, lennie says “I don’t want ta hurt you” (Steinbeck 91).
Why did Lennie shoot George?
George was a really good friend and he would never be able to see Lennie in pain so he had no other option but to kill him to just save him from the misery the ranch workers were going to put him in.
Why does George lie about Lennie having the gun?
Why does George lie about the gun? Because they would have killed Lenny anway. Why does Slim treat George as he does? He feels bad for him and he feels that George did the right thing by killing Lenny.
What does George do while telling Lennie the story?
He tells him the story of the farm they were going to buy. What does he do while telling him this story? George shoots Lennie and kills him.
What does Slim say to George at the end?
Why does Slim say,You hadda, George. I swear you hadda? he knows that George feels terrible about having to kill Lennie. He was the only one who had sympathy for him because he understood the relationship between George and Lennie.
What does George lie to Lennie about near the end of the book?
George speaks for Lennie, making the Boss suspicious. George lies, telling him that Lennie is his cousin and he looks after him because he was kicked in the head by a horse as a child.
What is Lennie’s disability?
Of Mice and Men remains a staple text in schools in both the United States and United Kingdom, where both neuro-typical and disabled pupils encounter it. The character of Lennie has learning difficulties and also—as identified by some researchers—exhibits many characteristics of autism.
Is George a good friend?
In the novel Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, George is a good friend to Lennie although he may seem to be inhumane because he kills Lennie at the end of the novel. When Lennie and George have an argument and Lennie offers to go away and live in a cave so that he does not bother George anymore.
What is the last thing that George wants Lennie to know why is this important to him?
The last thing George wants Lennie to know is that he isn’t mad at Lennie, and that someday they will achieve their dream. This is important to him as he wanted Lennie to know that, before he dies, he is reassured that his best friend isn’t mad about his actions.
What are Lennie’s two hallucinations?
1. While he is waiting for George in the clearing, what two hallucinations does Lennie have? Lennie has a hallucination of a big rabbit and a hallucination of his aunt Clara.
Why did George feel he needed to carry out Lennie’s execution at the end of the novel?
His aunt Clara. Why did George felt that he had to carry out the execution? Either as retribution for Lennie’s crime or before the other men would get to Lennie.
Why is George innocent?
Many people believe that George is guilty because he and Lennie could have gotten away but, George is innocent because he also knew that if he did not kill lennie he would suffer when Curley got to him. “You don ‘t know that Curley, Curley gonna wanna get him lynched Curley will get him killed”Steinbeck.
What is an example of George protecting Lennie?
In fact, George acts as a parent toward Lennie: He treats Lennie as one would treat a child, he laughs a great deal at Lennie’s words, and because he knows how much Lennie likes soft things, he promises to try to get Lennie a puppy and to let him care for the rabbits when they finally get their own ranch.
What kind of relationship do George and Lennie have Why?
Throughout the novel, George and Lennie have a relationship like a master and his dog. George is responsible for Lennie, making sure he has work, food, and does not get into too much trouble. He gives Lennie commands, which Lennie is supposed to obey, and when Lennie does not, George scolds him.
When George shoots Lennie is it an act of cruelty and kindness?
Although shooting Lennie seems cruel or inappropriate, this was done out of the kindness of George’s heart. He believed it would be less painful than if Curley caught Lennie. Two alternate decisions would have been to let Lennie go to jail (if Curley didn’t kill him) or go to a mental asylum.
Was George justified in killing Lennie quizlet?
Why did George kill Lennie and was he justified in doing that? He killed Lennie because he knew that the other ranchers would kill him and he did not want him to die by their hands so he shot Lennie himself. He was not justified in doing that.
Who is the only one who really understands what George did explain?
2. Who is the only one who really understands what George did? When the men arrived, Slim was the only one who could sympathize with George. Because of their earlier conversation, he understood the relationship between George and Lennie.
What alternatives did George have to shooting Lennie?
George realises that the other options are to send Lennie from his side into a mental institution where he would be a danger to himself and a danger to others, or to run to the next town again, to complete the cycle once more and to have again someone else killed and to again have to run from another gang.
Is Lennie a violent person do you think he understands when he does something wrong?
Lennie is not a violent person. He does understand when he is getting hurt and he understands the fear of recrimination from George. … Lennie doesn’t understand that the punishment for killing someone will be very serious. This shows that he is a child.
Why do you think George chooses to shoot Lennie is this choice fair to Lennie Why or why not?
George tells lennie the story to distract him and put him in his happy place before he dies. why do you think George chooses to shoot lennie? is this choice fair to Lennie? why or why not? he chooses to shot lennie so that he doesn’t have to suffer from curley.
How does George show cruelty to Lennie?
George knows that if Curley kills Lennie, it will be cruel and he will suffer. To prevent this from happening, George kills Lennie by shooting him “between the spine and the base of the skull” (a reference to Candy’s dog), and says it should be painless and he wouldn’t even know.
Why did George lie about what really happened?
Why did George lie to the others about what really happened? So they wouldn’t know that he had taken the gun or to think he had anything to do with Curley’s wife’s death. He would be able to stay on the ranch and keep working.
Is her dream any more realistic than George and Lennie’s?
3.Is her dream any more realistic than George’s and Lennie’s? No, Curley’s wife dreams wasn’t as realistic because she dreamed of becoming a movie star in hollywood.
What does Lennie’s death represent?
Lennie’s death is symbolic of the death of the American dream. Neither Lennie nor George ever get to the farm they always talked about. The novel begins with dreams of wanting something more, but in the end, Lennie’s dreams are killed along with him.
Why does Lennie hallucinate at the end of the story?
2) They show his worst fears. Lennie is afraid of being abandoned, and these hallucinations show this. 3) They show the unattainability of his dreams. His Aunt Clara is dead, and he will never get to tend the rabbits he dreams of.
What are some of George’s last words to Lennie?
What are some of George’s last words to Lennie? No, Lennie, I ain’t mad. I never been mad, an I ain’t now.